Officer Scott: Too Much Isn't Enough

The cult favorite comedy with music, Officer Scott, returns to Brooklyn Art Haus for a string of shows confirmed for spring 2026.

Created and performed by Sloan Brettholtz and co-written and directed by Bailey Nassetta, the outrageous solo show blends absurd humor, audience participation, and raw vulnerability into a wildly original theatrical experience.

Officer Scott follows a deeply committed NYPD officer who is offered the one thing he has always wanted: a sanctioned partner. The catch is that he must successfully deliver a D.A.R.E presentation to an auditorium full of fourth graders. When the presentation spirals out of control and Scott falls for a substitute teacher, his faith in the system begins to fracture. Rejected by his precinct and abandoned by the institution he devoted his life to, Scott is forced to confront who he is beyond the badge.

Guided by a giant butterfly conjured from his rage, Scott embarks on a surreal, drug induced Christmas Carol style journey where Jesus, his late mother, and the original cast recording of A Chorus Line reveal what life could look like if he dared to believe he was worthy of love. The result is a psychedelic, participatory comedy where no one in the audience stays on the sidelines.

Featuring: Sloan Brettholtz, Aaron Applebey, Jared Palmer Kirsch, Deirdre Manning, and Christopher Morucci